Hi,
I gained in my first week too. I was pretty bummed - I was good and stayed on plan, but I did use pretty much all of my points. I'm not keen on the idea of cutting my points because all through my life I have eaten too much, apart from a brief period where I ate far too little, so I have no idea what my body needs or how to judge it for myself. I don't really have a hunger radar. If 29 ProPoints a day plus the 49 ProPoints a week is supposedly the minimum I need, that's what I want to stick to. I thought about cutting it down but I'm worried about becoming obsessive about it again.
It could have been a number of things that caused the gain, but essentially it was either the way my body was reacting, or I wasn't eating the right sorts of food. I'm not sure if a 5 ProPoint ciabatta would have the same effect on my weight as 5 ProPoints worth of skinless chicken breast... So I am trying it again for a week, maybe eat more veg etc, and more protein (I love meat but don't eat huge amounts of it, same with eggs, pulses... can't stand fish though). I liked the old plan because I didn't have to drastically change the food I was eating, I just had to restrict the amount. But this one I think the type of food might be more important than the points value. I feel a lot more like I am "on a diet" on ProPoints, with all the counting and label checking and complex calculations, but that could just be because it's new. I like the premise behind ProPoints, encouraging healthy balance and so on, so I hope I take to it. But if it's not working for me by January I might have to rethink whether or not Weight Watchers is for me.