Xenical v Reductil

I came off Xenical in October due to ill health, when I saw another doctor before Xmas he changed me to Reductil saying it would make me feel full up and not want to eat.

However I don't feel any different, I've put a stone back on and I'm having trouble sleeping (one of the side effects)

Has anyone tried this drug and how did you get on with it in comparrison?

I havn't tried reductil although my sister went on it for a while. It has worse side effects than Xenical can cause depression and even suicidal. Sorry couldnt be of more help.